The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, commonly referred to as “The Hague Convention” is a multilateral treaty ratified between Australia and numerous other countries. This treaty assists those seeking the return of abducted children to their home country, and provides processes in which a parent can seek to have their child returned.
When a parent removes a child out of their home country, without the consent or knowledge of the other parent, the procedures in getting the child back is an incredible complex process, however the enforcement of the Hague Convention through Australian domestic law makes international child abduction a punishable offence. This is through the Family Law (Child Abduction Convention) Regulations 1986 (Cth) (“the Regulations”).
When a child is abducted to Australia, it is primarily the role of the Attorney General’s Department or the Department of Communities and Justice to satisfy the requirements under the Hague Convention, and the Regulations require Australian courts to order the return of a child to his/her home country unless certain specific and exceptional circumstances exist. The best interest of the child is not a paramount consideration and the discretion of a court to refuse to order the return of a child to his/her home country is very limited. The same standards are imposed by the Hague Convention on all signatories of the treaty.
If a child is abducted to a country that is not a part of the Hague Convention, then you may seek assistance from the Consular Branch of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, or an application may be made under the other country’s local laws.
If you are concerned that the other parent of family member may take a child without your knowledge or consent, you should seek immediate legal advice in order to ensure the safety and wellbeing of the child.
Should you wish to discuss this matter further, please do not hesitate to contact our offices on 02 8917 8700.
In Australia, 1.5% (4,754) of women who gave birth in 2021 were under the age of 20.
Whilst the key focus in a teen pregnancy should be on receiving proper health care and support, these are the legal facts you should be aware of:-
Telling others
- The law does not require someone who is undergoing a teen pregnancy to tell family members, their parents, or anyone who is close to them.
Receiving treatment
- A doctor will need to assess and determine whether the patient is able to consent to medical treatment, without the supervision of parents, if you are under the age of 18. The doctor may consider the patient’s maturity (their ability to comprehensively understand the potential outcomes of a pregnancy, and the required steps of treatment to ensure wellbeing and safety), their age, and the severity or seriousness of the need for treatment.
- If a doctor decides that the patient has a capacity to consent, medical treatment may be discussed and serviced with no requirement to have parent’s knowledge or consent. This will mean that any treatment or information discussed will be confidential.
- If a doctor decides that you do not have the capacity to provide your informed consent, they may request for a parent’s involvement and consent.
Terminating a pregnancy
- The law states that the individual who is undergoing a teen pregnancy is the person who will decide if the pregnancy should be terminated.
- The consent of the intimate partner is not required.
- There is no requirement to seek the consent of parents (if you are over the age of 16). Someone who is pregnant and under the age of 16 must discuss with a health care professional, social worker, or counsellor if they are unable to tell their parents.
Ultimately, it is crucial for anyone undergoing a teen pregnancy to speak with a health care professional, social worker, or counsellor in order to fully understand the options and consequences of pregnancy and treatment.
Services which provide support include: your local GP, The Women’s Information Service, SHINE SA, Kids Help Line, Legal Help Line, Family Planning NSW, ReachOut, and many others.
If you or someone you know wish to discuss this issue further, then please do not hesitate to contact us on 02 8999 9809.
Sources:
https://lsc.sa.gov.au/cb_pages/young_people_and_pregnancy.php
https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/mothers-babies/australias-mothers-babies/contents/focus-population-groups/teenage-mothers
The Cab Rank Principle is a rule outlined by the Legal Profession Uniform Conduct (Barristers) Rules 2015 – Regulation 17 which outlines that a barrister must accept a brief from a solicitor or client to appear before a court if:
- The brief is within the barristers expertise and skills;
- The barrister is not already committed to other professional engagements which would prevent them from accepting the brief, and
- The fee offered is acceptable;
(A brief contains a summary of information that is given to barristers regarding a case with legal points that they are able to utilise in proceedings in court.)
The term “Cab rank” rule is derived from the idea that a Barrister must act on a first come, first serve basis, similar to the way a cab driver must drive the next person in like at the rank. This principle is a foundational to the Bar and comes back to the rule of law; the idea that no individual is above the law and hence it should be equally accessible and applicable to everyone. The rule has a further basis in that a barrister does not only owe a duty to their client, but also a duty to the administration of justice and thus they must maintain high standards of professional conduct.
As Justice Brennan said:
“The observance of the rule is essential to the availability of justice…it is unacceptable that the privileges of legal representation should be available according to the predilections of counsel or only on the payment of extravagant fees. If access to legal representation before the courts were dependent on counsel’s predilections as to the acceptability of the cause or the munificence of the client, it would be difficult to bring unpopular causes to court and the profession would become the puppet to the powerful” – Giannarelli v Wraith (1988) 165 CLR 453.
Presently, this rule is only applicable to legal professionals who practice as barristers but there have been discussions as to whether this is a rule that should also apply to solicitors considering that all legal professionals, irrespective of whether they practice as barristers, conduct their work primarily to serve the community. Solicitors are also officers of the law and also have their own duties to uphold justice. Thus, if they are able to pick and choose the cases they work on, there may be a danger that those who may be perceived to have unfavourable cases by the public, or those that are marginalised, may be denied access to justice.
Once again noting that lawyers do not only have a duty to clients, but also the wider community and the legal system, it is important to have discussions about the rule and what it will look like in the future.
If you or someone you know wish to discuss this issue further, then please do not hesitate to contact us on 02 8999 9809.
On 6 August 2023, the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) announced Australia’s first police referral pilot in New South Wales (NSW). The pilot will aim to revolutionise how banks report technology-facilitated abuse, utilising artificial intelligence and other technologies to alert law enforcement.
In the age of digital banking and ‘apps’, bank users are more susceptible than ever to technological abuse. To combat this threat, CBA utilises a range of interventions to make online banking safer. For example, CBA blocks over 400,000 transactions annually by using artificial intelligence to detect inappropriate language sent via the CommBank app. The newly announced police reporting pilot, which will launch in mid-September of this year, will take safety precautions to the next level, and allow CBA to identify repeat abuse faced by victims. CBA will then reach out to the victim and ask consent to contact NSW police to report the abuse.
As a result, users will be provided with a streamline and fast process of reporting abuse. This pilot will not only support victims, but will also prevent abuse, paving the way ‘for more effective collaboration in the fight against domestic and financial abuse’ said Angela Macmillan of CBA Group Customer Advocate.
If you or someone you know with to discuss the issue further, please do not hesitate to contact our offices on (02) 8917 8700.
If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic or family violence, call 1800RESPECT (1800 737 732) or visit www.1800RESPECT.org.au.
In an emergency or if you’re not feeling safe, always call 000.
Jumping into pop-culture news for this article from F&G, let’s follow the most recent legal battles relating to conservatorships in America, and how that translates to guardianship laws in NSW.
Britney Spears' Conservatorship
Public knowledge about conservatorships boosted exponentially following the debacle that was Britney Spears’ 13-year conservatorship, which was terminated after nearly 14 years by a Los Angeles court ruling in November 2021. Spears’ case revealed the extreme lengths to which an individual living under a conservatorship or a guardianship order, can be governed – including her being unable to remove a contraceptive device so she could fall pregnant.
ABC News notes that 1.3 million Americans live under strict conservatorships. Australia does not have conservatorships as they exist in the United States. Instead, each state and territory harbour various guardianship and financial management laws which mimic the function of a conservatorship. A report by the Australian Guardianship and Administration Council notes that there are a total of 19,879 guardianship and administration/financial management orders active between 1 July 2021 and 30 June 2022.
The NSW Equivalent of an American Conservatorship
In NSW, guardianship orders can be sought for individuals seeking to appoint another person with the ability to make decisions about their health, accommodation, services and other lifestyle matters. Similar to the conditions of Britney Spears’ conservatorship, individuals subject to a guardianship order are not able to consent themselves to medical and dental treatment. There are limitations on who can be the subject of a guardianship order. Unfortunately, these limitations still raise significant concerns about the impact of substituted-decision making where supported-decision making can be more beneficial for some individuals under guardianship orders.
The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) is responsible for reviewing guardianship applications and making orders. The NCAT will only grant a guardianship order, where the following requirements are satisfied:
- The person being subject to the order has a decision-making disability and is over the age of 16;
- The consequence of the disability is such that the person is partially or wholly incapable of managing themselves; and,
- There is a need for the person to have a guardian appointed.
The Intended Purpose of a Guardianship Order vs the Practical Effect
As these requirements highlight, guardianship orders are intended to serve as ‘support’ mechanisms for those with a disability – this may be a mental health condition, an intellectual disability, or a disability affecting someone’s ability to communicate their decisions. The Guardianship Act 1987 (NSW) states that the welfare and interests of persons with disabilities should be given paramount consideration and that their freedom should be restricted as little as possible.
In practice, however, there are minimal checks and balances on how a guardian undertakes their role to substitute an individual’s capacity and consent with their own – which is discussed by the Intellectual Disability Rights Service in this report. Australia has also been subject to criticisms by the United Nations. Despite being a signatory to the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), the UN finds that Australia has failed to adhere to the values and principles of the CRPD, by continuing to implement substituted decision-making regimes that enshrine restrictive practices.
If you or someone you know wish to discuss this issue further, please do not hesitate to contact our offices on (02) 8917 8700.
Breaking news from 9 News Australia on Wednesday 9 August 2023 followed the story of a woman who was dismissed from her 18-year tenure at an insurance company, after her employer was unsatisfied with her work productivity and performance while working from home. What may seem a normal instance of workplace dismissal was made more controversial by the fact that the woman’s employer had been monitoring her laptop activity through logged keystrokes and assessing the amount of work she was doing from home.
Understandably, this has raised concerns from employees regarding their right to privacy in light of employers’ rights.
Is it legal for employers to spy on employees in this manner?
Yes – in NSW, employers can monitor the usage of equipment provided to employees for work purposes. Actions to be monitored can generally include time spent on work-issued devices such as laptops and phones, as well as the content of movements on such devices (i.e. text messages on a work phone). Reports also identify employees tracking location, mouse movements, and capturing screenshots.
How is this data obtained?
With the intention of more accurately measuring productivity and efficiency outside of the physical workspace, employee monitoring software saw a significant rise in demand during the COVID pandemic. The use of such spyware on company-supplied equipment has continued into the post-pandemic era, and concerns arise where the focus of the tool turns to surveillance and control. In most circumstances, employers must also notify employees of the software being installed on work-issued devices and explain what is being monitored, 14 days prior to the installation of such software.
What can employees do to protect themselves?
The key action to take is to check the terms of your employment contract and your workplace policy. These documents are essential as they:
- outline the extent to which your employer is entitled to monitor uses of work-issued equipment
- state the expectations of employee conduct in the course of work and consequences of failing to meet set standards.
As the panel discussion for the program noted, the increase of working-from-home arrangements and its normalisation during and after the peak of the COVID pandemic has ushered both positives and complexities in how workplaces function. The flexibility offered by work-from-home arrangements enable greater employee engagement and productivity for some. However, issues arise where the benefits are misused and create an imbalance between privacy protections for employees and employers right to enforce a standard of workplace conduct.
If you or someone you know wish to discuss this issue further, please do not hesitate to contact our offices on (02) 8917 8700.
TW: domestic abuse
Domestic violence is a complex and silent crime that is significantly under-reported, and in most cases, survivors find it difficult in accessing avenues of help.
Domestic violence involves an abuse of power, and is predominantly targeted towards women – making it a gendered crime. It extends beyond physical violence, and manifests itself in various forms including financial abuse, psychological abuse, sexual abuse and isolation.
An avenue that is accessible to many survivors is their healthcare provider or general practitioner. Especially if your partner has isolated you from friends and family, a healthcare provider might be one’s only safe form of communication. When speaking to your general practitioner, advise them of your domestic violence situation, and if your partner refuses to leave you alone in the room with the general practitioner, attempt to call (during a safe time) the general practitioner beforehand to let them know that you wish to speak to them alone.
After discussing your situation with the general practitioner, they will be in a position to assist you in making a safety plan, provide you with details of local resources, and even document the abuse you are going through, whether that be physical or mental. You may need to check beforehand the state laws regarding whether general practitioners are required to report any incidents to the police, especially if you wish for no report to be made.
F&G understands how difficult it is for survivors of domestic violence to finally break free from the power their partner dominates over them and speak out about their situation. It is important to always have a thorough self-care process, such as doing something you enjoy, journaling, or even practicing breathing techniques.
There are numerous assistance helplines available to you:-
- NSW Domestic Violence Line - 1800 656 463
- 1800 RESPECT- 1800 73 77 32
- Link2home Homelessness - 1800 152 152
- Child Protection Helpline - 13 21 11
If you or someone you know wish to discuss this issue further, then please do not hesitate to contact us on 02 8999 9809.
Separated – but in the same house?
The Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) governs the legal requirements for a divorce in Australia. Although it seeks to minimise the number of obstacles faced by married or de facto couples intending to separate, the complexity of the law itself can be a barrier faced by individuals in the community.
One such area of confusion is the legal requirement for separation to obtain a divorce. Where no children are involved, a divorce order is only granted where the Court considers there is an irretrievable breakdown of the marriage. This is proven by demonstrating to the Court that you and your partner separated and lived separately for a continuous 12-month period before filing an application for divorce.
However, it is often the case that couples are not in a financial position, or simply do not want, to move from their primary residence and to different accommodation while undergoing the separation process. Further complexities arise where children under the age of 18 are involved, as a divorce will not be granted unless there are proper arrangements made for them.
What many do not realise is that the meaning of separation under section 49 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) does account for the circumstance where parties to a marriage have continued to reside in the same residence since separation. The focus of the Court’s consideration of your separation is that you have ‘lived separately and apart’. This can be evidenced by further explaining your specific circumstances to the court in an affidavit (a sworn written document), where you would outline key facts such as:
- the date of separation and how it was established;
- the reasons for why either party could not reside somewhere else;
- the practical changes to your relationship after separation, including;
- changed sleeping arrangements;
- division/separation of finances; and/or
- the plans for either parties’ place of residence after granting of the divorce.
Your affidavit addressing matters such as those listed above, will be filed alongside your divorce application to support your request to the Court. If you are independently applying for a divorce, you must file the affidavit yourself and would also benefit filing an affidavit by an independent person who knows you. If you and your partner are both applying for a divorce, an affidavit must be filed separately by each of you.
At Freedman & Gopalan Solicitors, we understand that every couple and family face unique and varying personal circumstances which may complicate how the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) applies to you.
If you or someone you know wish to discuss this issue further, then please do not hesitate to contact us on 02 8999 9809.
From July 18 to August 17, Australians are called to embrace, appreciate, and reflect on the rich culture and history of South Asia. Famously celebrated for its diversity in arts, food, and identities, South Asia is comprised of Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka.
South Asian Heritage Month is dedicated to developing greater engagement, education, and awareness on South Asian cultures, and encouraging fellow South Asians to reflect on their heritage.
This year’s South Asian Heritage Month theme is:
Stories to Tell
Celebrating, Commemorating, Educating
How can you participate in South Asian Heritage Month?
- Celebrate the culture, and everything in between – South Asia encompasses a rich culture of creativity, entertainment, food, and more. Engaging in these cultural aspects, for example, may take the form of watching a Nepali movie, reflecting on Indian artworks or enjoying Bangladeshi music.
- Commemorate the contributions South Asians have made to our contemporary society. Researching the origins of modern food or music allows for a deeper realisation on South Asia’s impact on today.
- Educate yourselves and others by developing an understanding on the cultures, strides, sufferings, and accomplishments of South Asia to further respect and acknowledge the history of the nations.
In honour of South Asian Heritage Month, it is worth researching and attending a South Asian event for a first-hand experience of its cultures. A few events over the course of the next two months can be found below.
- Sydney to Mumbai: Australian Indian Orchestra – 13 August 2023
- The Spice Route of India - Cooking Class – 17 August 2023
- South Asian Film Art & Literature Festival – 23 September 2023, 30 September 2023
If you or someone you know wish to discuss this issue further, then please do not hesitate to contact us on 02 8999 9809.
Image Source:
https://www.behance.net/search/projects?search=bangladeshi+folk+art
